Guest follow-up with a bivocational pastor and a part-time admin
Greeters hand out paper welcome cards on Sunday (no time for an iPad in a 30-minute turnaround). The part-time admin enters guests into Tithely on Tuesday. The bivocational pastor texts every guest personally by Wednesday. Incremental cost: $0 on top of the $72/mo system.
What are the exact steps?
- Sunday: paper cards and a printed roster
Greeters hand out paper welcome cards and mark a printed attendance roster. Paper is a deliberate choice: the church rents a 1:30 pm slot and has thirty minutes to set up sound, the kids room, and the welcome table. There is no time to boot an iPad. Cards ask for name, phone, email, and language preference (the service runs in English and Spanish).
- Bag cards to the admin before anyone leaves
After the service, one greeter puts cards in a labeled envelope for the admin. Do not leave them in a jacket or under a music stand. The room must be clear for the host congregation. Capture happens at the door; data entry waits for Tuesday on purpose.
- Tuesday: the admin's day
The part-time admin works about ten hours a week, and Tuesday is the day. She enters attendance and the guest cards into Tithely Church Management (the church's people and giving system, formerly Breeze). One login for records and giving is why it is the system. She learned it in one afternoon. Flat $72/mo means the bill does not grow every time they start a ministry.
- Tuesday evening: admin texts the pastor the guest list
She sends the pastor a short list: name, phone, anything written on the card. That handoff is the bridge between her ten hours and his bivocational week at the transit authority. If a card has no phone, she notes email only and he sends a short email instead.
- By Wednesday: the pastor texts every guest himself
A personal text from the pastor's own phone: 'It was really good to meet you, can I buy you a coffee near your stop?' The subway reference is intentional; almost everybody at this church arrives by train. One text per guest. If they reply, he books coffee. If they do not, he does not chase daily.
- Write the vacation backup before you need it
When the pastor is away, the admin still enters cards, then either holds texts until he returns (if under three days) or sends a soft welcome from a shared church number. His own next step is that shared number plus written steps anyone could run. Last summer three guests got nothing when he was gone a week.
Which tools does this church use?
- Paper welcome cards + printed roster Forms
Guest capture on Sunday. Deliberately paper: no time to set up an iPad in a 30-minute room turnaround.
$0
- Tithely Church Management (formerly Breeze) Church database (ChMS)
Where the admin enters attendance and guest cards on her Tuesday.
$72/mo flat (runs the whole church)
- The pastor's phone Texting
Every guest gets a personal text from the pastor by Wednesday. Also the workflow's single point of failure.
$0
Common questions
How does a tiny church afford guest follow-up software?
This church spends $72 a month total on software. Tithely Church Management is flat-rate because the pastor did not want a bill that grows every time they start a ministry. Everything else is paper, WhatsApp, and free Google tools.
What's the weakness of pastor-driven guest follow-up?
It lives on one person's phone. When this pastor was away for a week last summer, three guests got nothing. His next step is a shared church number the admin can text from, plus written steps anyone could run.
Should a small church use digital check-in for guests?
Not necessarily. This church rents a room with a 30-minute setup turnaround, so paper cards and a printed roster win. Capture happens at the door; data entry moves to the admin's Tuesday.
Before you start
You need paper welcome cards, a printed roster, Tithely Church Management access for the admin, and a clear Tuesday handoff to the pastor. Decide language on the card (this church offers English and Spanish). Name a backup greeter who knows where the envelope goes after service. If follow-up currently lives only in the pastor’s head, write the three-day rule on paper before you change tools.
Why they built it
The constraint stack is total: one bivocational pastor, one admin at ten hours a week, a rented room with a 30-minute turnaround, and a $72 monthly software budget. Every choice in this workflow is the cheapest thing that still gets a guest a personal touch within three days.
The pastor is honest about the weakness: follow-up lives on his phone. When he was away for a week last summer, three guests got nothing. A workflow that only works when one specific person is healthy and in town is not a workflow. It is a habit. His fix list is the right one: a shared church number the admin can text from, and the steps written down so anyone could run them.
What they’d do differently
Write the steps down from day one. Buy the shared church number before the next vacation week. The other slow-motion problem is WhatsApp: the group has gradually become the church directory, and not everyone in it should see everyone’s number. Nobody has solved that one yet. They are watching it.
Monday checklist
- Confirm Sunday’s card envelope reached the admin (or is waiting for her Tuesday).
- Tuesday: admin enters attendance and guests into Tithely.
- Tuesday evening: guest list with phones reaches the pastor.
- Wednesday: pastor sends one personal text per guest.
- Note replies and coffee plans; no daily chase texts.
- Before any pastor travel: decide who texts, from which number, with which script.
Common mistakes
- Trying to run iPad check-in in a 30-minute rented-room turnaround.
- Leaving cards in personal bags after teardown.
- Automating a “welcome campaign” the pastor will never read replies from.
- Skipping texts when the week at the transit job runs long.
- Putting guest phone numbers into the main WhatsApp group.
Field note after a missed vacation week
Three first-time guests from the Sunday the pastor traveled heard nothing. Two came back anyway. One did not. The admin had entered the cards on Tuesday and waited for him. Waiting without a backup rule is how kindness fails. They now write the coverage plan before he leaves town.
Field note after a subway coffee reply
A guest replied to the “coffee near your stop” text with a station name and a time. The pastor met her there on his lunch break from the transit job. The line on the text was not cute branding. It matched how people actually move through the city. Specific beats generic hospitality copy.
The Monday digest
One short Monday email with a complete how-to for churches your size: named tools, ordered steps, and real cost. Reply anytime. A person reads it. Unsubscribe in one click.
Almost in. Check your email and confirm before we send the Monday how-to.